Continued from previous post.
Saturday's Fish set started with him walking in the crowd, as
Vigil opened the proceedings.
Vigil is one of the most powerful songs from the Fish back catalogue, and this was a good rendition. This led into
Assassing, which had the whole crowd in thrall. To be honest, Foss Paterson [keyboards] doesn't do this song justice, and that did detract from the performance. It's a great song, but I have seen tribute bands perform this with more accuracy and energy.
Fish was introducing some of the songs by their age, and this set people's mind racing at once, trying to guess which it might be. While this was fun for a couple of songs, I can't help thinking that it robbed the setlist of some of its suspense.
I often complain about Fish's neglect of his early-to-mid solo career, but this weekend has made up for a lot of that. We got
Brother 52, from 1997's masterpiece
Sunsets on Empire, and
Mr 1470 from 1994's
Suits, both of which are firm favourites of mine. Also aired was one of the few tracks I like from
Fellini Days [2001],
Clock Moves Sideways. The venom was almost tangible, and the performance the best I remember.
Incubus [from Marillion's
Fugazi, 1984], often quoted as Fish's favourite work, was stunning, although I do miss Mickey Simmonds on keyboards for this. After that, frankly, the set took a nosedive, which was to see people lose interest, and in some cases, walk out: most recent album
13th Star, almost in its entirety.
This section suffered on quite a few levels. One, it's a very downbeat record, with very repetitive songs, and almost nothing to brighten its mood. Two: most of the tracks have been played at nearly every show for the last two years, and we are the kind of fanbase that go to multiple shows on each leg of a tour. Thirdly, the album didn't flow well when performed in one go. Unfortunately, on top of that, the monitor engineer was having trouble with the onstage sound, and Fish threw a strop at him. This went beyond what was reasonable, in my view, and soured the atmosphere further. Talking to some people after the show, I was told of people who walked out of the gig during this section, and from my own perspective near the front, I felt the energy go out of the crowd like a deflating balloon. I've tried to keep my own strong dislike of the album out of this criticism: even some of those who love the album were disinterested by the end of it.
Fish and band left the stage in what was clearly not the best of humours - it must have been obvious that the atmosphere in the hall wasn't what it should have been, and Fish's unhappiness with the monitors was tangible - I felt that we only got an encore by default. That this encore opened with fan favourite
Fugazi helped immensely! Final encores of Marillo B-side
Freaks (really not one of my favourites, although most fans were mad for it) and the ultimate show-stopper
Market Square Heroes rescued this gig from being remembered as a complete duffer, in my view. Here's the complete set, pinched (and edited) from the Union Forum:
Vigil
Assassing
Brother 52
Mr 1470
Numbers
Clock Moves Sideways
Incubus
Circle Line
Square Go
Miles De Besos
Zoe 25
Arc Of The Curve
Manchmal
Openwater
Dark Star
13th Star
Fugazi
Freaks
Market Square Heroes
The show finished at a little before half-past midnight. Sue and I said our goodbyes to those friends who we were with, chatted briefly with a few of them and then walked back to the B&B.
On Sunday morning, we had breakfast (this time with black pudding - excellent!) and went into town in time for Sue to join in with the Penguin Hunt, organized by the Company Gloster's resident lunatic Jez (although officially credited to Doc Bob, for some reason). I wasn't interested in that, so hung around with Cez and Howard for a few pints, first outside Dockers, the pub next to the venue, until I ran them out of the one ale they did, Goose Island, and later back in the Jug and Jester. We chatted about music until the Hunt finished and people returned. The weather was still beautiful, so the Penguin Hunt proved fairly popular. After another pint or two, we went into the venue for the next official event.
Fish and Mickey Simmonds were reclining with glasses of wine in some large chairs on stage, with comedic tour memories, eventually joined by Yatta [long-standing tour manager]. This was very amusing, and then the stage was set for Never Mind the FishHeads, a TV-inspired quiz compered by comedian Will Smith (the English comedian, not the Hollywood actor). The teams were Foss, Fish and Gavin [Griffiths, drums]; and Mark Wilkinson, Mickey and Frank, with Fish and Mickey team captains. It was clearly scripted to some extent, and piss-funny. The high point of the convention so far.
After the quiz, the raffle was drawn, and the winners announced on stage. Also, Frank's 60th birthday gift from the fans was presented.
This evening's support band was The Reasoning, a band I first saw supporting Fish last year. I wasn't convinced then, and this set didn't alter that. They have had a line-up change or two since the last time I saw them, adding an acoustic guitarist (superfluous to requirements, I think) and a rather buxom second female singer (ditto). The music is roughly prog metal of good quality, but I don't think it works as a whole, and certainly not in this configuration. One to watch, though, especially given developments since. I think they have it in them to create some excellent stuff, but I don't think that their sound has matured yet.
Fish's set started with the Marillion classic
Script for a Jester's Tear, and went through a set of Fish solo classics, with highlights of
Credo,
Poet's Moon (first time out in about sixteen years),
Tongues and the sublime
View from a Hill. There's a list of some of my favourite Fish songs right there, so it goes without saying that I thoroughly enjoyed myself!
This was followed by the first side of
Misplaced Childhood, which has been done, and better, dozens of times on the 20th anniversary tour which Fish undertook from 2005 to 2006. That said, it was still a great deal of fun, and set up the smashing encores of
Lucky (once-overplayed, but a welcome one-off performance),
Internal Exile and
The Company. This last had Mickey back playing onstage, and he did look happy. The only downside to the set was the omission of the piano intro to
Tumbledown, and the boring
Pilgrim's Address.
A cracking gig, with bucketloads of atmosphere, and a warm reception throughout. Another fantastic Fish fan convention!
Full set:
Script For A Jester's Tear
Credo
Innocent Party
Poet's Moon
Tumbledown
State Of Mind
The Pilgrim's Address
Tongues
Long Cold Day
The Voyeur
View From A Hill
Cliche
Pseudo Silk Kimono
Kayleigh
Lavender
Bitter Suite
Heart Of Lothian
Lucky
Internal Exile
The CompanyAfter the show, we held conversations with far too many people to mention, and finally trailed off to the B&B. Taff, Jase and I wandered off to the post-gig venue, Kelsey's, which was about the only pub in town still open after midnight on a Sunday, and had one last one while we said our goodbyes to those who weren't staying with us.
In the morning, we parted fondly with the people who were staying at our guest house, and drove back north with Mike and Debbie, since Mike's car was still kaputt from blowing its head gasket, in the local garage. We had lunch with them in Warrington, and then hit the road south after yet more goodbyes!
A Fish convention is always a blast, and we went back to work on Tuesday feeling as if we'd been off for a fortnight! Let's not wait three years for the next one, eh, Fish?